Republican tax reformers seem to believe that their cap of $1.5 trillion in 10-year tax cuts is not enough to both substantially cut family taxes and overhaul the outdated business tax code. Nonsense. By combining the best parts of the House and Senate bills, and closing some additional tax loopholes, lawmakers could make available an additional $500 billion to expand the child tax credit to $2,000, extend the new $300 family flexibility credit and expand the earned income tax credit.

The main purpose of tax reform is to update America's outdated, punitive business tax code. The 35 percent corporate tax rate (39 percent including state taxes) dwarfs the typical 24 percent rate our trading partners face. Even after accounting for business tax loopholes, America's effective corporate tax rate exceeds all G20 countries except Japan and Argentina. Additionally, America's outdated worldwide tax system – among the last in the world – charges an exorbitant tax rate that exports jobs and investment overseas, yet raises almost no tax revenue from the affected multinational companies.

A large majority of economists agree that modernizing America's business tax system will create jobs and raise incomes, even if they argue over the magnitude. Thus, both the House and Senate tax reform bills would lower the corporate tax rate to 20 percent (24 percent with state taxes), allow businesses to immediately deduct the full cost of new investments, replace our worldwide tax system with a common territorial system and cut taxes for small businesses.


RELATED CONTENT

RELATED CONTENT

A Tax Plan Worthy of Praise

The Senate tax plan would spur economic growth, increase wages and create jobs.


But what about family tax cuts? Fitting business tax reform within the $1.5 trillion cap leaves room for family tax cuts of just $216 billion in the House plan, and $525 billion in the Senate plan. The House would also allocate $151 billion to killing the estate tax, while the Senate applies $94 billion to merely limiting it.

Overall, under the House plan, for instance, the average family in the middle-income quintile would see its tax cut decline from $840 next year to just $320 a decade from now as some tax cuts expire. Nearly one-third of these families would see an eventual tax increase.

We can do much better for families – without gutting the business tax cuts or busting the $1.5 trillion cap.

My "Bipartisan Blueprint" begins by merging the best of the House and Senate bills to reduce the cost to $1.25 trillion.

First, it adopts the Senate business tax proposal, which provides all the vital business tax cuts listed above, but costs $200 billion less than the House bill because it more aggressively cracks down on business tax preferences and loopholes. That is an acceptable price to pay for all the new business benefits.


Cartoon Gallery
Editorial cartoon on bitcoin
Editorial cartoon on Republican tax cuts and the economy
Editorial cartoon on Republican tax plan and the national debt
Editorial cartoon on the Republican Party and tax cuts and the middle class
Editorial cartoon on tax cuts
Editorial cartoon on GOP tax plan and the national debt
Editorial cartoon on banks and Congress
Editorial cartoon on U.S. economy and corporate taxes
Editorial cartoon on Jeff Bezos and Amazon
Editorial cartoon on automation and the economy
Editorial cartoon on minimum wage and businesses
Editorial cartoon on Google and Amazon
Editorial cartoon on housing prices
Editorial cartoon on minimum wage and jobs
Editorial cartoon on college debt and housing costs
|

Steve Breen/Creators Syndicate

Michael Ramirez/Creators Syndicate

Steve Breen/Creators Syndicate

Chan Lowe/Tribune Content Agency

Jack Ohman/Tribune Content Agency

Scott Stantis/Tribune Content Agency

Dan Wasserman/Tribune Content Agency

Michael Ramirez/Creators Syndicate

Dan Wasserman/Tribune Content Agency

Michael Ramirez/Creators Syndicate

Steve Breen/Creators Syndicate

Chan Lowe/Tribune Content Agency

Gary Markstein/Creators Syndicate

Steve Breen/Creators Syndicate

Steve Breen/Creators Syndicate

Chan Lowe/Tribune Content Agency

Jack Ohman/Tribune Content Agency

Steve Breen/Creators Syndicate

Scott Stantis/Tribune Content Agency

Michael Ramirez/Creators Syndicate

David Horsey/Tribune Content Agency

Ken Catalino/Creators Syndicate

Michael Ramirez/Creators Syndicate

Gary Markstein/Creators Syndicate

David Horsey/Tribune Content Agency

Steve Breen/Creators Syndicate

Marshall Ramsey/Creators Syndicate

Scott Stantis/Tribune Content Agency

Ken Catalino/Creators Syndicate

Scott Stantis/Tribune Content Agency

David Horsey/Tribune Content Agency

Steve Breen/Creators Syndicate

David Horsey/Tribune Content Agency

Scott Stantis/Tribune Content Agency

Drew Sheneman/Tribune Content Agency

Michael Ramirez/Creators Syndicate

Dan Wasserman/Tribune Content Agency

Michael Ramirez/Creators Syndicate

Walt Handelsman/Tribune Content Agency

Steve Breen/Creators Syndicate

Dana Summers/Tribune Content Agency

Dan Wasserman/Tribune Content Agency

Dan Wasserman/Tribune Content Agency

Dan Wasserman/Tribune Content Agency

Drew Sheneman/Tribune Content Agency

Steve Breen/Creators Syndicate

Drew Sheneman/Tribune Content Agency

Dana Summers/Tribune Content Agency

Michael Ramriez/Creators Syndicate

Dan Wasserman/Tribune Content Agency

Jack Ohman/Tribune Content Agency

Steve Breen/Creators Syndicate

Chan Lowe/Tribune Content Agency

Drew Sheneman/Tribune Content Agency

Chan Lowe/Tribune Content Agency

Steve Breen/Creators Syndicate

Dan Wasserman/Tribune Content Agency

Tom Stiglich/Creators Syndicate

Dan Wasserman/Tribune Content Agency

Chan Lowe/Tribune Content Agency

Gary Markstein/Creators Syndicate

Dana Summers/Tribune Content Agency

Gary Markstein/Creators Syndicate

David Horsey/Tribune Content Agency

Steve Breen/Creators Syndicate

Steve Breen/Creators Syndicate

Tom Stiglich/Creators Syndicate

Steve Breen/Creators Syndicate

David Horsey/Tribune Content Agency

Walt Handelsman/Tribune Content Agency

Dan Wasserman/Tribune Content Agency

Steve Benson-Creators Syndicate

Drew Sheneman-Tribune Content Agency

Gary Markstein-Creators Syndicate

Drew Sheneman-Tribune Content Agency

Scott Stantis-Tribune Content Agency

Jack Ohman-Tribune Content Agency

Drew Sheneman-Tribune Content Agency

Jack Ohman-Tribune Content Agency

Tom Stiglich-Creators Syndicate

Michael Ramirez-Creators Syndicate

Jack Ohman-Tribune Content Agency

Tom Stiglich-Creators Syndicate

Dan Wasserman-Tribune Content Agency

Dana Summers-Tribune Media Services

David Horsey-Tribune Media Services

Gary Markstein-Creators Syndicate

Chris Britt-Creators Syndicate

Dan Wasserman-Tribune Media Services

Dan Wasserman-Tribune Media Services

Dan Wasserman-Tribune Media Services

Dan Wasserman-Tribune Media Services

David Horsey-Tribune Media Services

Marshall Ramsey-Creators Syndicate

Dan Wasserman-Tribune Media Services

Dan Wasserman-Tribune Media Services

Michael Ramirez-Creators Syndicate

Steve Breen-Creators Syndicate

Drew Sheneman-Tribune Media Services

Scott Stantis-Tribune Media Services

Dick Locher-Tribune Media Services

Dick Locher-Tribune Media Services

Steve Breen-Creators Syndicate

Dick Locher-Tribune Media Services

Walt Handelsman-Tribune Media Services

Scott Stantis-Tribune Media Services

Dan Wasserman-Tribune Media Services

Dana Summers-Tribune Media Services

Michael Ramirez-Creators Syndicate

Dick Locher-Tribune Media Services

Mike Thompson-Creators Syndicate

Walt Handelsman-Tribune Media Services

Walt Handelsman-Tribune Media Services

Gary Markstein-Creators Syndicate

Marshall Ramsey-Creators Syndicate

Steve Breen-Creators Syndicate

Dan Wasserman-Tribune Media Services

Drew Sheneman-Tribune Media Services

Walt Handelsman-Tribune Media Services

Marshall Ramsey-Creators Syndicate

Clay Jones-Creators Syndicate

Gary Markstein-Creators Syndicate

Dan Wasserman-Tribune Media Services

Steve Breen—Creators Syndicate

Mike Thompson—Creators Syndicate

David Horsey-Tribune Media Services

Drew Sheneman-Tribune Media Services

Walt Handelsman-Tribune Media Services

Dana Summers-Tribune Media Services

Walt Handelsman-Tribune Media Services

Walt Handelsman-Tribune Media Services

Gary Markstein-Creators Syndicate

Matt Davies-Tribune Media Services

Walt Handelsman-Tribune Media Services

Steve Benson-Creators Syndicate

Gary Markstein-Creators Syndicate

Walt Handelsman-Tribune Media Services

Marshall Ramsey-Creators Syndicate

Jack Ohman—Tribune Media Services

Michael Ramirez-Creators Syndicate

Gary Markstein-Creators Syndicate

Steve Breen—Creators Syndicate

Chris Britt-Creators Syndicate

Dana Summers-Tribune Media Services

Michael Ramirez-Creators Syndicate

John Sherffius-Creators Syndicate

Steve Breen—Creators Syndicate

Gary Markstein-Creators Syndicate

Gary Markstein-Creators Syndicate

Walt Handelsman-Tribune Media Services

Mike Thompson—Creators Syndicate

Michael Ramirez-Creators Syndicate

Dana Summers-Tribune Media Services

Gary Markstein-Creators Syndicate

Dana Summers-Tribune Media Services

Michael Ramirez-Creators Syndicate

Michael Ramirez-Creators Syndicate

Michael Ramirez—Creators Syndicate

Gary Markstein-Creators Syndicate

Chan Lowe—Tribune Media Services

Dick Locher—Tribune Media Services

Dana Summers—Tribune Media Services

Walt Handelsman—Tribune Media Services

Jack Ohman—Tribune Media Services

Drew Sheneman—Tribune Media Services

Dana Summers—Tribune Media Services

Marshall Ramsey—Creators Syndicate

Michael Ramirez—Creators Syndicate

Dan Wasserman—Tribune Media Services

Gary Markstein—Creators Syndicate

Mike Thompson—Creators Syndicate

Dick Locher—Tribune Media Services

Michael Ramirez-Creators Syndicate

John Sherffius-Creators Syndicate

Editorial cartoon on bitcoin
Editorial cartoon on Republican tax cuts and the economy
Editorial cartoon on Republican tax plan and the national debt
Editorial cartoon on the Republican Party and tax cuts and the middle class
Editorial cartoon on tax cuts
Editorial cartoon on GOP tax plan and the national debt
Editorial cartoon on banks and Congress
Editorial cartoon on U.S. economy and corporate taxes
Editorial cartoon on Jeff Bezos and Amazon
Editorial cartoon on automation and the economy
Editorial cartoon on minimum wage and businesses
Editorial cartoon on Google and Amazon
Editorial cartoon on housing prices
Editorial cartoon on minimum wage and jobs
Editorial cartoon on college debt and housing costs
Editorial cartoon on air traffic control and privatization
Editorial cartoon on Wonder Woman and gender pay gap
Editorial cartoon on graduation and automation
Editorial cartoon on U.S. economy and debt
Editorial cartoon on U.S. economy and regulations
Editorial cartoon on the economy and automation
Editorial cartoon on college graduation and jobs
Editorial cartoon on the economy and taxes and regulations
Editorial cartoon on President Donald Trump and tax cuts
Editorial cartoon on jobs and automation and immigration
Editorial cartoon on Amazon and the economy
Editorial cartoon on U.S. economy and the dow
Editorial cartoon on economy and jobs and technology
Editorial cartoon on President Barack Obama and national debt
Editorial cartoon on U.S. economy
Editorial cartoon on U.S. economy and taxes and Donald Trump
Editorial cartoon on summer and vacation and jobs
Editorial cartoon on blue collar workers and unemployment and technology
Editorial cartoon on the economy and interest rates
Editorial cartoon on hedge funds and the economy
Editorial cartoon on President Barack Obama and U.S. economy
Editorial cartoon on economy and unions
Editorial cartoon on economy and minimum wage
Editorial cartoon on Panama Papers and economy
Editorial cartoon on economy and minimum wage
Editorial cartoon on China and the economy
Editorial cartoon on wages
Editorial cartoon on raising the minimum wage
Editorial cartoon on the economy and wages
Editorial cartoon on the economy
Editorial cartoon on the economy
Editorial cartoon on the economy and jobs
Editorial cartoon on income inequality
Editorial cartoon on finance
Editorial cartoon on jobs, education and economy
Editorial cartoon on Tim Geithner
Editorial cartoon on fast food strikes
Editorial cartoon on graduation.
Editorial cartoon on the economy.
Editorial cartoon on American middle class
Editorial cartoon on equal pay
Editorial cartoon on retirement
Editorial cartoon on jobs and technology
Editorial cartoon on General Motors recalls
Editorial cartoon on minimum wage
Editorial cartoon on job creation
Editorial cartoon on the economy.
Editorial cartoon satirizing the economy.

Steve Breen/Creators Syndicate

Michael Ramirez/Creators Syndicate

Steve Breen/Creators Syndicate

Chan Lowe/Tribune Content Agency

Jack Ohman/Tribune Content Agency

Scott Stantis/Tribune Content Agency

Dan Wasserman/Tribune Content Agency

Michael Ramirez/Creators Syndicate

Dan Wasserman/Tribune Content Agency

Michael Ramirez/Creators Syndicate

Steve Breen/Creators Syndicate

Chan Lowe/Tribune Content Agency

Gary Markstein/Creators Syndicate

Steve Breen/Creators Syndicate

Steve Breen/Creators Syndicate

Chan Lowe/Tribune Content Agency

Jack Ohman/Tribune Content Agency

Steve Breen/Creators Syndicate

Scott Stantis/Tribune Content Agency

Michael Ramirez/Creators Syndicate

David Horsey/Tribune Content Agency

Ken Catalino/Creators Syndicate

Michael Ramirez/Creators Syndicate

Gary Markstein/Creators Syndicate

David Horsey/Tribune Content Agency

Steve Breen/Creators Syndicate

Marshall Ramsey/Creators Syndicate

Scott Stantis/Tribune Content Agency

Ken Catalino/Creators Syndicate

Scott Stantis/Tribune Content Agency

David Horsey/Tribune Content Agency

Steve Breen/Creators Syndicate

David Horsey/Tribune Content Agency

Scott Stantis/Tribune Content Agency

Drew Sheneman/Tribune Content Agency

Michael Ramirez/Creators Syndicate

Dan Wasserman/Tribune Content Agency

Michael Ramirez/Creators Syndicate

Walt Handelsman/Tribune Content Agency

Steve Breen/Creators Syndicate

Dana Summers/Tribune Content Agency

Dan Wasserman/Tribune Content Agency

Dan Wasserman/Tribune Content Agency

Dan Wasserman/Tribune Content Agency

Drew Sheneman/Tribune Content Agency

Steve Breen/Creators Syndicate

Drew Sheneman/Tribune Content Agency

Dana Summers/Tribune Content Agency

Michael Ramriez/Creators Syndicate

Dan Wasserman/Tribune Content Agency

Jack Ohman/Tribune Content Agency

Steve Breen/Creators Syndicate

Chan Lowe/Tribune Content Agency

Drew Sheneman/Tribune Content Agency

Chan Lowe/Tribune Content Agency

Steve Breen/Creators Syndicate

Dan Wasserman/Tribune Content Agency

Tom Stiglich/Creators Syndicate

Dan Wasserman/Tribune Content Agency

Chan Lowe/Tribune Content Agency

Gary Markstein/Creators Syndicate

Dana Summers/Tribune Content Agency

Gary Markstein/Creators Syndicate

David Horsey/Tribune Content Agency

Steve Breen/Creators Syndicate

Steve Breen/Creators Syndicate

Tom Stiglich/Creators Syndicate

Steve Breen/Creators Syndicate

David Horsey/Tribune Content Agency

Walt Handelsman/Tribune Content Agency

Dan Wasserman/Tribune Content Agency

Steve Benson-Creators Syndicate

Drew Sheneman-Tribune Content Agency

Gary Markstein-Creators Syndicate

Drew Sheneman-Tribune Content Agency

Scott Stantis-Tribune Content Agency

Jack Ohman-Tribune Content Agency

Drew Sheneman-Tribune Content Agency

Jack Ohman-Tribune Content Agency

Tom Stiglich-Creators Syndicate

Michael Ramirez-Creators Syndicate

Jack Ohman-Tribune Content Agency

Tom Stiglich-Creators Syndicate

Dan Wasserman-Tribune Content Agency

Dana Summers-Tribune Media Services

David Horsey-Tribune Media Services

Gary Markstein-Creators Syndicate

Chris Britt-Creators Syndicate

Dan Wasserman-Tribune Media Services

Dan Wasserman-Tribune Media Services

Dan Wasserman-Tribune Media Services

Dan Wasserman-Tribune Media Services

David Horsey-Tribune Media Services

Marshall Ramsey-Creators Syndicate

Dan Wasserman-Tribune Media Services

Dan Wasserman-Tribune Media Services

Michael Ramirez-Creators Syndicate

Steve Breen-Creators Syndicate

Drew Sheneman-Tribune Media Services

Scott Stantis-Tribune Media Services

Dick Locher-Tribune Media Services

Dick Locher-Tribune Media Services

Steve Breen-Creators Syndicate

Dick Locher-Tribune Media Services

Walt Handelsman-Tribune Media Services

Scott Stantis-Tribune Media Services

Dan Wasserman-Tribune Media Services

Dana Summers-Tribune Media Services

Michael Ramirez-Creators Syndicate

Dick Locher-Tribune Media Services

Mike Thompson-Creators Syndicate

Walt Handelsman-Tribune Media Services

Walt Handelsman-Tribune Media Services

Gary Markstein-Creators Syndicate

Marshall Ramsey-Creators Syndicate

Steve Breen-Creators Syndicate

Dan Wasserman-Tribune Media Services

Drew Sheneman-Tribune Media Services

Walt Handelsman-Tribune Media Services

Marshall Ramsey-Creators Syndicate

Clay Jones-Creators Syndicate

Gary Markstein-Creators Syndicate

Dan Wasserman-Tribune Media Services

Steve Breen—Creators Syndicate

Mike Thompson—Creators Syndicate

David Horsey-Tribune Media Services

Drew Sheneman-Tribune Media Services

Walt Handelsman-Tribune Media Services

Dana Summers-Tribune Media Services

Walt Handelsman-Tribune Media Services

Walt Handelsman-Tribune Media Services

Gary Markstein-Creators Syndicate

Matt Davies-Tribune Media Services

Walt Handelsman-Tribune Media Services

Steve Benson-Creators Syndicate

Gary Markstein-Creators Syndicate

Walt Handelsman-Tribune Media Services

Marshall Ramsey-Creators Syndicate

Jack Ohman—Tribune Media Services

Michael Ramirez-Creators Syndicate

Gary Markstein-Creators Syndicate

Steve Breen—Creators Syndicate

Chris Britt-Creators Syndicate

Dana Summers-Tribune Media Services

Michael Ramirez-Creators Syndicate

John Sherffius-Creators Syndicate

Steve Breen—Creators Syndicate

Gary Markstein-Creators Syndicate

Gary Markstein-Creators Syndicate

Walt Handelsman-Tribune Media Services

Mike Thompson—Creators Syndicate

Michael Ramirez-Creators Syndicate

Dana Summers-Tribune Media Services

Gary Markstein-Creators Syndicate

Dana Summers-Tribune Media Services

Michael Ramirez-Creators Syndicate

Michael Ramirez-Creators Syndicate

Michael Ramirez—Creators Syndicate

Gary Markstein-Creators Syndicate

Chan Lowe—Tribune Media Services

Dick Locher—Tribune Media Services

Dana Summers—Tribune Media Services

Walt Handelsman—Tribune Media Services

Jack Ohman—Tribune Media Services

Drew Sheneman—Tribune Media Services

Dana Summers—Tribune Media Services

Marshall Ramsey—Creators Syndicate

Michael Ramirez—Creators Syndicate

Dan Wasserman—Tribune Media Services

Gary Markstein—Creators Syndicate

Mike Thompson—Creators Syndicate

Dick Locher—Tribune Media Services

Michael Ramirez-Creators Syndicate

John Sherffius-Creators Syndicate

×

Next, my blueprint adopts the House family tax proposal, which costs $300 billion less than the Senate side. The House plan better simplifies tax rates, provides more generous tax credits and more aggressively limits tax preferences.

Finally, the blueprint adopts the House estate tax repeal that is supported by a bipartisan majority of voters.

But we're not done yet. An additional $250 billion can be saved with four tweaks: First, set the new small business tax deduction at 15 percent rather than 17.4 percent. Second, adopt the House's more aggressive one-time "toll charge" on multinational company funds parked abroad. Third, delay estate tax repeal for another year. And fourth, kill the "step-up basis" loophole that allows heirs to inherit large assets without having to pay capital gains taxes on the pre-death profits.

Altogether, these reforms would free up $512 billion for added family tax cuts – hiking the total from $216 billion to $728 billion. Business tax cuts would total $711 billion, and estate and inheritance reforms would come to $61 billion.


RELATED CONTENT

RELATED CONTENT

This Isn't Reagan's Tax Reform

The tax plan Republicans are pitching today is nothing like the bipartisan bill that passed in 1986.


Three family tax cuts could each be expanded. The $1,000 per-child tax credit – currently proposed at $1,600 – could soar to $2,000. The new temporary family flexibility tax credit ($300 per adult) could be extended. And the earned income tax credit could be expanded for childless workers who barely benefit from the current version and obviously do not benefit from the expanded child credit.

Remember that typical middle-income family who would receive a $320 tax cut a decade from now? My blueprint would instead provide $1,720 – all while preserving the business community's needed 20 percent corporate tax rate, investment expensing, small business tax relief and territorial system.

Republicans are betting on tax reform to rescue their declining popularity heading into the 2018 elections. Yet tax reform ranks as a low priority for most voters because many do not anticipate significant benefits. Expanding family tax cuts while preserving the pro-growth business tax reforms should be a no-brainer. Are lawmakers listening?

Tags: taxes, corporate taxes, tax code, tax cuts, business, family, Republican Party


Brian Riedl is a senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute. Follow him on twitter @Brian_Riedl.

Recommended Articles

Cartoons on President Donald Trump

Nov. 30, 2017, at 5:18 p.m.

Political Cartoons on the Economy

Dec. 8, 2017, at 4:57 p.m.

Stop the Trump Derangement Syndrome

Peter Roff | Dec. 14, 2017

Cavalierly suggesting the president is mentally ill is bad for the country.

A Backdoor Tax on the Middle Class

Bob Lord | Dec. 14, 2017

By cutting the estate tax, Republicans are just asking the middle class to pick up the tab.

White Women's Bad Bargain

Colleen Butler-Sweet | Dec. 14, 2017

Why do so many white women vote for misogynists?

End Everyday Gun Violence

Elizabeth Charash | Dec. 14, 2017

5 years after Sandy Hook, lawmakers aren't addressing the shootings that plague many communities.

How to Sustain Our Special Forces

Phillip Lohaus | Dec. 14, 2017

It's time to rethink the role of special operations forces in relation to the rest of government.

Daily Cartoons: December 14, 2017

Dec. 14, 2017, at 12:01 a.m.

The GOP Rots From the Top

Ashley Pratte | Dec. 13, 2017

The Alabama election shows Republicans must do more to prevent Trump from destroying the party.

Squandering America

Charles Wheelan | Dec. 13, 2017

The U.S.'s dysfunctional politics are putting all of its advantages at risk.